Argentum. Please. [hey kaiba maybe please start using first names for people no okay nevermind then carry on] Keep up a lotion treatment and you'll look fine. [kaiba please]

We know we're missing memories. Ages in our profiles seem to reflect a later time point for some, for example. Nobody that I'm aware of has suggested that they look different. So it's possible that we came here with memories to a certain point, and thus, our manifestations of our physical selves are from what we recall ourselves as.

...But you're suggesting something more like time travel?